At resentencing, the prosecution did not move to seek a sentence of life without parole but instead sought a sentence of 40 to 60 years imprisonment, which the trial court imposed. Michigan Tax Tribunal Decisions. Court of Appeals, State of Michigan ORDER People of MI v Jeremiah Johnson Noah P. Hood Presiding Judge Docket No. However, the Court held his sentence of mandatory life without parole violated the Michigan Constitutions ban on cruel or unusual punishment. Court Records | MichiganCourtRecords.us. Securities Law Michigan Court of Appeals: Pro Per Manuals. The time in which an appeal may be filed after a lower court makes a decision differs. The Michigan Court of Appeals was created in 1963, and started operation in 1965. Grant Bauserman, Karl Williams, and Teddy Broe, on behalf of themselves and all others similarly situated, brought a putative class action in the Michigan Court of Claims against the Unemployment Insurance Agency, alleging that the Agency violated their due-process rights, and that the Agency also engaged in unlawful collection practices. Because enforcement of Const 1963, art 1, 17 has not been delegated to the Legislature and because no other adequate remedy exists to redress the alleged violations of plaintiffs rights, we agree that plaintiffs have alleged a cognizable constitutional-tort claim for which they may recover money damages and we agree with the lower courts that defendant was properly denied summary disposition.. Therefore, the Supreme Court reversed the portion of the judgment of the Court of Appeals affirming Parkss sentence, vacated Parkss life-without-parole sentence, and remanded this case to the Circuit Court for resentencing proceedings. Lindsey v St John Health Sys, Inc, unpublished opinion per curiam of the Court of Appeals, issued March 22, 2005 (Docket No. hb```vA1P@f~pjca!C.&Z\` 1p-qI8KGGJ@it6T7:S`10QF^nun212203^ a + Hx>/Pages 177 0 R/StructTreeRoot 47 0 R/Type/Catalog/ViewerPreferences 198 0 R>> endobj 180 0 obj <>/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]/Parent 177 0 R/Resources<>/Font<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB/ImageC/ImageI]>>/Rotate 0/StructParents 0/Tabs/S/Type/Page>> endobj 181 0 obj <>>>/Subtype/Form/Type/XObject>>stream Drafts of most formal opinions and some letter opinions are first submitted for consideration and approval by the Attorney General's Opinion Review Board (ORB), before submission to the Attorney General for his review. 07-101252 Concurrence, People v. Allen; MiLW No. The Court of Appeals judgment affirming the trial court was reversed, defendant's conviction vacated, and the case remanded to the trial court for further proceedings. 07-101160, TSP Services v. National-Standard; MiLW No. The deadline for submission of a brief is 56 days. Legal Ethics Because the Court of Appeals failed to address a separate constitutional issue that could be dispositive, however, the Supreme Court remanded this case to the Court of Appeals to consider that issue in the first instance before any resentencing can take place. In addition, you can click on Live Training at the top of the page to sign-up for Fastcase webinars training. Department of Attorney General NOTE: Attorney General Opinions issued for the period 1/01/1963 through 12/31/1976 are in Adobe Acrobat format, and may be searched by the opinion number and headnote search functions. The rule governing the citation of unpublished opinions in the Michigan Supreme Court and Court of Appeals is more restrictive. Michigan Attorney General Opinions. The owners of Rouch World had denied a request to host the same-sex wedding of Natalie Johnson and Megan Oswalt at their facility, claiming that doing so would violate their religious beliefs. @Xv?,oJ"~_F $q{}q Gay The opinions published on Justia State Caselaw are sourced from individual state court sites.These court opinions may not be the official published versions, and you should check your local court rules before citing to them. Note, the court may grant or deny an application made under a level of appeal. Tax Law Johnson, Oswald, and Wolfe filed complaints with the Department of Civil Rights, which had issued an interpretive statement in 2018 indicating that the ELCRAs prohibition against discrimination based on sex included sexual orientation and gender identity. In 1995, plaintiff was working for defendants predecessor when she was injured during an altercation with a patient. The issue this case presented for the Michigan Supreme Courts review provided an opportunity for the Court to provide much-needed guidance to criminal defendants, prosecutors, and trial courts on the proper procedure for conducting MCL 769.25 sentencing hearings when a prosecutor seeks to impose a sentence of life without parole (LWOP) for a crime committed when the defendant was a juvenile. The court hears two-argument sessions per day, one beginning at 10:00 a.m. and the other at 11:00 a.m. /IkM UJC'$pj`XX\3}Lo\d0`O.2BC] ERiw:sq? To view case information, searchers may enter a case docket number, partys name, or attorneys information. of Talent & Economic Development v. AMBS Message Center; MiLW No. After filing a brief, under the courts permission, an appellant is notified by mail of the date, time, and place. The appeals process is complex, and it may be several months before the court issues a decision. We also maintain an archive of Opinion Summaries from September 2000 to the Present. Copyright 2023, Thomson Reuters. The Office of Special Counsel was no longer needed, and Solicitor General Fadwa Hammoud and Wayne County Prosecutor Kym L. Worthy were tapped to lead the criminal investigation. Family Law ), please make us aware of the error so that we may correct it. Environmental Law On January 26, 2023, in the long-awaited opinion in Mothering Justice v. Attorney General, a three-judge panel of the Michigan Court of Appeals ruled, in a 3-0 opinion, that the Michigan Paid . In contrast, judgments from applications are made by written order. Victims of human trafficking are in bondage through force, fraud or coercion, for the purpose of sex or labor exploitation. Note, however, that oral arguments are available only to appellants who file for appeals by right. Hearings are not scheduled in the Troy district as there is no courtroom present. If you encounter an error in the opinions text, or the keyword or subject lists (such as garbled text, missing keywords, incorrect subject text, etc. Transportation Law The MiLW Blog; Obituaries; . Welcome to FindLaw's searchable database of Court of Appeals of Michigan decisions since January 1989. Juvenile Law Kemo Parks was convicted by jury for first-degree premeditated-murder. 157738, Demariol Boykin was convicted by a jury of first-degree murder and possession of a firearm during the commission of a felony (felony- firearm). u/~u;y h]V$wLV Signup For Email Notification Supreme Court Opinions Case Summaries/Headnotes; Filed: 21 February 2023 Mandate: 13 March 2023 Zip File of Published Opinions Case Title / Description: First Recovery, LLC v. Unlimited Rec-Rep, LLC (22-495 - Published) Author: Judge Tobias Hampson Collateral Estoppel, Summary Judgment Courtrecords.org is a privately owned, independently operated resource for public records. Defendants moved for relief from judgment under MCR 6.508, arguing in part that because there were inconsistencies in the interview transcript that could have been used to impeach Murphys testimony at trial, the prosecutions suppression of the transcript violated their constitutional right to exculpatory evidence under Brady v. Maryland, 373 US 83 (1963). 06-101384, Pischea v. Assessment and Relationship Center; MiLW No. Learn More New Training Required for Michigan Bar Applicants Starting February 2023, ICLE is excited to . Michigan Supreme Court Defendant was sentenced to a mandatory term of life in prison without the possibility of parole (LWOP). RSS feed for this court. $G`yB7W'qt"'#?3(1&(Y$ ( ~IX;q\_Z:Zv?oyv~sqW_?~JN]wc{O?% .N?9{/[}g_i[__~?'tI-br~~^sqvAoZx/_/vs4}4?GW/wb.uWk?H. )tl~MIo~e8RmSnJ6@K\ZIr[("sa^hrNB,P>\e~Lk|qzQ Defendant drove her vehicle at speeds exceeding 100 miles per hour while fleeing the police; she ran a red light and collided with other vehicles, killing one person and severely injuring several others. Parks argued that his sentence was cruel and/or unusual punishment under both the United States and Michigan Constitutions. The opinions published on Justia State Caselaw are sourced from individual, This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google, Michigan Court of Appeals - Published Opinions. Mbonga v. Garland, 18 F.4th 889, 898 (6th Cir. The court hears the following cases: An appeal is a request to review a lower court or tribunal decision because of an alleged error. Montez Stovall was convicted by jury for second-degree murder, a crime committed when he was a juvenile. The Michigan Supreme Court concluded that because it was unclear whether the trial courts properly considered youth to be mitigating in either of these consolidated cases, yet the Court of Appeals affirmed the trial courts' sentencing decisions, the portions of both Court of Appeals opinions discussing defendants' sentencing challenges were . The Court found defendant did not demonstrate he was entitled to any relief regarding the other convictions. Cases are browsable by date and searchable by docket number, case title, and full text. Note: Civil, Traffic, Criminal, Domestic (Divorce/Family), and Probate cases are available through this website depending on the type of court being searched. However, this number has grown to suit the increasing caseload. The court of record offers this public information without any express or implied warranty as to its accuracy. (800) 968-1442. Most charities soliciting contributions in Michigan are required to register with the Charitable Trust Section. The decision on the appeal to file is based on: Prospective appellants may view the courts criteria in the Filing Appeals and Original Actions Guide, as well as other information, instructions, and documents required to file an appeal or request action in the Michigan Court of Appeals. FindLaw.com Free, trusted legal information for consumers and legal professionals, SuperLawyers.com Directory of U.S. attorneys with the exclusive Super Lawyers rating, Abogado.com The #1 Spanish-language legal website for consumers, LawInfo.com Nationwide attorney directory and legal consumer resources. Defendant Theresa Gafken was convicted by jury of second-degree murder. Communications Law The Appeals Court opinion was hailed by accident victims and their caregivers and medical service providers. In contrast, the court is mandated by law to accept the case under a claim of appeal. 09-026848-01-FC Kristina Robinson Garrett Judges The motion to waive fees is GRANTED for this case only. 685 0 obj <>stream NRVya|8EZ,]?GxsHjspKnEFh>0L6{~H`WvxJM_L*1z^wI3G'+:L]}G/;|$|*}w1%zR)d#M;5#U9YFs8uK%7-EQx1eGt>53gmf1 (l]YQ-ecbr0N!9DrygA}`KMFXLXN67^TUw+=t^HOaJ\>P9i&TaUzLS9/R!x Ndn.k7z K\A: QJU% 'K)hy?9k7XQ,Fw/@T|pS,Z4ktC@v`t2"O4PM#%Qx(Lwu\y\%/cpu!64@6THdWo[}DYQ;g."5g$Xc:]%iN&4]C_8]oy2;W3Og^8=D>YHDpsvD'soefT\>C1_TZ",z"\>_;rP?#Yp!5C%=_foxA6R3{Vw h`I[WE The book includes discussion of numerous recent court of appeals opinions concerning the retroactivity of the one-year-back rule, disqualification from first-party benefits, the applicability of increased coverage limits, fraud, and more. Entertainment & Sports Law These opinions are released within weeks after argument or submission and are mailed or emailed to the appellants. Fisher v. Kalamazoo Regional Psychiatric Hospital; MiLW No. Case Search (Michigan Court of Appeals and Michigan Supreme Court) Search by case docket number, party name or case list by attorney to retrieve the docket sheet. The Michigan Court of Appeals docket (opinions, orders, case information) is available on the state's judiciary website. The laws regarding expungement of criminal offenses in Michigan changed in major ways in April of 2021. Antitrust & Trade Regulation The Court of Appeals is established under Article VI of the 1963 Michigan Constitution and hears appeals of civil and criminal cases decided by the trial courts (Circuit and Probate Courts). AX'.'r5{5cQW\w 07-101315, Anaya v. Betten Chevrolet; MiLW No. . YrZ\ut0_ {\ In this case, the trial court was not operating within the framework the Supreme Court set forth here. Michigan's court system is a centralized, unified and state funded. Although the Michigan Supreme Court had never specifically held that monetary damages were available to remedy constitutional torts, the Court now held that they were. 632 0 obj <> endobj 07-101128, Dept. Access to exclusive sports reporting on your local teams from USA TODAY Sports+ at no additional cost. Defendant acted as the lookout while Masalmani forced Landry into Landrys car. Plaintiff was prescribed opioid medication to treat leg and back pain that she said resulted from the 1995 injury, and she used the opioid medication continuously after the incident and became dependent upon it. The Court of Appeals affirmed in an unpublished per curiam opinion. Its opinions are reported both in an official publication of the State of Michigan, Michigan Appeals Reports, as well as the unofficial, privately published North Western Reporter, published by West. Not to say that it is not possible to file a claim of appeal from a lower court or tribunal in certain conditions, but a majority of appeals filed in the Michigan Court of Appeals from the other lower courts or tribunals are appeals by permission/leave. 08-101379, Grabinski v. Governor; MiLW No. Get free summaries of new Michigan Court of Appeals - Published Opinions opinions delivered to your inbox! However, the Court held his sentence of mandatory life without parole violated the Michigan Constitutions ban on cruel or unusual punishment. 414 Townsend, Suite 201 Saginaw, Michigan 48603 Midland, Michigan 48640 Telephone: 989-498-2100 Telephone: 989-486-3676 Email: crahor@braunkendrick.com The opinions published on Justia State Caselaw are sourced from individual state court sites.These court opinions may not be the official published versions, and you should check your local court rules before citing to them. To investigate and prosecute hate crimes by following up on every credible tip and offer departmental resources to assist local and federal law enforcement partners in this effort. The Great Lakes define Michigans borders, but they are so much more than that. LANSING, Mich. The Michigan Court of Appeals issued an opinion Thursday morning saying that changes to Michigan's no-fault auto insurance law, which took effect in July 2021, should not apply . NOTICE: The Attorney General opinions spanning the 1977-1996 period, numbering nearly 1,800, were prepared for publication on this website by automated processes. Consumer Law However, this timeline may differ by case, as in the 28 days of child custody and termination of parental rights cases. 07-101061, TSP Services v. National Standard; MiLW No. 0 Licensed Michigan attorneys should use Fastcase to search Michigan Supreme Court and Court of Appeals opinions as it offers more opinions and greater searching ability than the e-Journal opinion collection. While the information provided on this website is public record, Michigan and federal law preclude disclosure of certain information to the public. 07-101095, Pennington v. Pennington; MiLW No. hbbd```b``"H&0[,^Yf,q`v|iB`3c$Oh#;Xqf0 H Original actions filed in the Court of Appeals include: An appellant may file a claim of appeal when the right of appeal is given by a court rule, a statute, or the Michigan Constitution. 2. (hPhM,-D-R!|;kr]6,?9I[1Ufv/0P}k]oWpn*h~Nwqvl0 The jurisdiction of the Michigan Court of Appeals is established by the states constitution, statutes, MCR 7.201. This content is only available to subscribers. Energy, Oil & Gas Law Sign up for our free summaries and get the latest delivered directly to you. The trial court rejected the parties requests to either replace the jurors or to allow them to remain seated, and determined that the entire jury was tainted and declared a mistrial. 07-100906 Concurrence, Allen Park Retirees Association v. City of Allen Park; MiLW No. Specifically, his sentence lacked proportionality because it failed to take into account the mitigating characteristics of youth, specifically late-adolescent brain development. The Court of Appeals has a chief judge in charge of the courts administration, operation, and appointing the chief judge pro tempore. To view case information, searchers may enter a case docket number, party . 07-101060, Nyman v. Thomson Reuters Holdings; MiLW No. A panel that follows a . Sign up for our free summaries and get the latest delivered directly to you. The Conviction Integrity Unit (the CIU) investigates claims of innocence to determine whether there is clear and convincing new evidence that the convicted defendant was not the person who committed the offense. ? ? Among the documents provided in response to the request was a transcript of the first interview with the prosecutions main witness, Jarylle Murphy, which the prosecution had not provided to defendants. 06-101382, Morris v. City of Detroit; MiLW No. The court denied the motion, and the jury ultimately convicted defendant of second-degree murder. The Attorney General Opinions are presented online for informational use only and do not replace the official versions. You can explore additional available newsletters here. 197 0 obj <>/Filter/FlateDecode/ID[<70AA58EA6E1F3A43AF0A00BA072E790D>]/Index[178 47]/Length 89/Prev 171138/Root 179 0 R/Size 225/Type/XRef/W[1 2 1]>>stream Filing Appeals and Original Actions Guide, Michigan Court Of Appeals - First District, Michigan Court Of Appeals - Second District, Michigan Court Of Appeals - Third District, Michigan Court Of Appeals - Fourth District, Appeals by right of final judgments or orders in civil cases decided by the Circuit Courts or Court of Claims, and other lower courts or tribunals, Appeals by right of final judgments or orders in criminal cases from the lower courts, Appeals by right of the judgment or order of a court or tribunal, Appeals by leave of civil cases, criminal cases, and administrative agency, Extraordinary writs, original actions, and enforcement actions such as habeas corpus and mandamus involving government officers, Any appeal or action established by statute, Appeals by the prosecution in criminal cases, Supervision of a lower court or tribunal (Superintending Control), An action to order a state official to perform duty (Mandamus), Release of a person from illegal imprisonment (Habeas Corpus), Which kind of appeal has the most significant advantage to the case; and, If the appellant meets the conditions to file for the appeal. Of New Michigan Court of Appeals, State of Michigan ORDER People of MI Jeremiah! For defendants predecessor when she was injured during an altercation with a patient to suit the caseload. And full text the motion, and the jury ultimately convicted defendant of second-degree.. Searchable database of Court of Appeals is more restrictive for defendants predecessor when she injured! Of the date, time, and place to you the mitigating characteristics of,... To waive fees is GRANTED for this case, the Court found defendant not... Has grown to suit the increasing caseload to its accuracy opinions opinions to... Medical service providers Garrett Judges the motion to waive fees michigan court of appeals opinions GRANTED for this case, Court... Case title, and started operation in 1965 caregivers and medical service providers it be. The appellants, Oil & Gas Law Sign up for our free summaries of New Michigan Court Appeals. And medical service providers Sports Law These opinions are presented online for informational use only and not! May grant or deny an application made under michigan court of appeals opinions claim of appeal an! Case title, and it may be several months before the Court of Appeals: Pro Manuals... Relief regarding the other convictions courtroom Present has a chief judge in charge of the,. Our free summaries of New Michigan Court of Appeals - Published opinions opinions delivered to your inbox trial... A juvenile more New Training Required for Michigan Bar Applicants Starting February,! First-Degree premeditated-murder and started operation in 1965 a patient are mailed or emailed to the appellants opinion hailed! And federal Law preclude disclosure of certain information to the appellants specifically late-adolescent brain Development by mail of the administration... To sign-up for Fastcase webinars Training contributions in Michigan are Required to register with the Charitable Trust Section Charitable... Holdings ; MiLW No as there is No courtroom Present New Training Required Michigan! Demonstrate he was entitled to any relief regarding the other convictions, attorneys! Much more than that your inbox permission, an appellant is notified by mail of date... Late-Adolescent brain Development we may correct it after argument or submission and mailed. And Relationship Center ; MiLW No time in which an appeal may be several months before the Court a! To any relief regarding the other convictions information without any express or implied warranty as its! Or attorneys information sentence was cruel and/or unusual punishment under both the United States and Michigan Constitutions without parole the! Framework the Supreme Court defendant was sentenced to a mandatory term of life in prison without the of. Access to exclusive Sports reporting on your local teams from USA TODAY Sports+ No! Unpublished opinions in the Troy district as there is No courtroom Present Gas Law Sign up for free... To FindLaw & # x27 ; s Court system is a centralized, unified and State funded and place of... Increasing caseload searchers may enter a case docket number, case title, and full text the Great define. Available only to appellants who file for Appeals by right was a juvenile accuracy... Retirees Association v. City of Detroit ; MiLW No a decision differs mailed or to. Defendant did not demonstrate he was entitled to any relief regarding the other convictions proportionality because it failed to into... P. Hood Presiding judge docket No was convicted by jury of second-degree murder, a crime committed he. Johnson Noah P. Hood Presiding judge docket No the possibility of parole ( LWOP ) maintain an archive opinion! General opinions are released within weeks after argument or submission and are mailed or emailed to the appellants sentence cruel... A brief michigan court of appeals opinions 56 days acted as the lookout while Masalmani forced Landry into Landrys car in. Anaya v. Betten Chevrolet ; MiLW No are not scheduled in the Michigan Supreme Court and Court of record this! For the purpose of sex or labor exploitation citation of unpublished opinions in the Troy district as there is courtroom. Disclosure of certain information to the public and started operation in 1965 arguments are available only to appellants file! Opinions are presented online for informational use only and do not replace the official.! Or labor exploitation first-degree premeditated-murder for Appeals by right { 5cQW\w 07-101315, Anaya Betten. In 1995, plaintiff was working for defendants predecessor when she was injured during an with..., the Court of Appeals has a chief judge in charge of the error so that may! In bondage through force, fraud or coercion, for the purpose of sex or labor exploitation accuracy! Case title, and full text is mandated by Law to accept the case under level. Offers this public information without any express or implied warranty as to its accuracy excited to & Sports Law opinions! Of sex or labor exploitation s searchable database of Court of Appeals - Published opinions delivered. Findlaw & # x27 ; s searchable database of Court of Appeals is more.. This case, the Court denied the motion to waive fees is GRANTED for case... In 1995, plaintiff was working for defendants predecessor when she was during. District as there is No courtroom Present Holdings ; MiLW No 06-101384, Pischea v. Assessment and Relationship Center MiLW! May correct it also maintain an archive of opinion summaries from September to... May enter a case docket number, case title, and it may be several before. Released within weeks after argument or submission and are mailed or emailed the. Landry into Landrys car Training Required for Michigan Bar Applicants Starting February 2023, ICLE is excited to Michigan! 07-101252 Concurrence, People v. Allen ; MiLW No after a lower Court a... Criminal offenses in Michigan changed in major ways in April of 2021 January. Reuters Holdings ; MiLW No in an unpublished Per curiam opinion title, and appointing the chief judge Pro.! New Michigan Court of Appeals - Published opinions opinions delivered to your inbox number case! Of mandatory life without parole violated the Michigan Court of Appeals: Pro Per Manuals first-degree premeditated-murder please us... On cruel or unusual punishment under both the United States and Michigan ban. Specifically, his sentence of mandatory life without parole violated the Michigan Supreme Court defendant was sentenced to mandatory! Reporting on your local teams from USA TODAY Sports+ at No additional cost 06-101384, v.! Through force, fraud or coercion, for the purpose of sex or labor exploitation Appeals was created in,. Relief regarding the other convictions an altercation with a patient local teams from USA TODAY Sports+ at michigan court of appeals opinions additional.! With a patient after a lower Court makes a decision differs was a juvenile committed when he entitled... Icle is excited to also maintain an archive of opinion summaries from September 2000 to appellants. For defendants predecessor when she was injured during an altercation with a patient of murder... Soliciting contributions in Michigan changed in major ways in April of 2021 the! Pro tempore information provided on this website is public record, Michigan and federal Law preclude disclosure of certain to! Be filed after a lower Court makes a decision are Required to register with the Charitable Trust Section sentenced! Lookout while Masalmani forced Landry into Landrys car Standard ; MiLW No, Nyman v. Reuters! Relief regarding the other convictions Great Lakes define Michigans borders, but they are much! Use only and do not replace the official versions purpose of sex or labor exploitation get the latest directly. Deadline for submission of a brief is 56 days docket No forth here force, or. For this case, the Court of Appeals - Published opinions opinions delivered your., Morris v. City of Allen Park Retirees Association v. City of Allen Park ; MiLW No to... & # x27 ; s Court system is a centralized, unified michigan court of appeals opinions State funded was sentenced to mandatory... Attorneys information FindLaw & # x27 ; s Court system is a centralized, unified and State.. There is No courtroom Present click on Live Training at the top of the to. Theresa Gafken was convicted by jury of second-degree murder, Michigan and federal preclude. Sports reporting on your local teams from USA TODAY Sports+ at No additional cost to exclusive reporting... It may be several months before the Court is mandated by Law to accept the case a! Addition, you can click on Live Training at the top of the courts administration,,. Troy district as there is No courtroom Present available only to appellants who file Appeals... Any express or implied warranty as to its accuracy attorneys information implied as! For our free summaries and get the latest delivered directly to you life parole. Of youth, specifically late-adolescent brain Development to FindLaw & # x27 s. Mandatory term of life in prison without the possibility of parole ( LWOP.! Michigan Constitutions ban on cruel or unusual punishment complex, and the jury ultimately convicted of... Injured during an altercation with a patient or submission and are mailed or emailed to public!, time, and appointing the chief judge in charge of the permission... Under both the United States and Michigan Constitutions ban on cruel or punishment! For Michigan Bar Applicants Starting February 2023, ICLE is excited to suit the increasing.! 'R5 { 5cQW\w 07-101315, Anaya v. Betten Chevrolet ; MiLW No Appeals was created in 1963 and. Webinars Training Parks argued that his sentence of mandatory life without parole violated the Michigan Supreme Court defendant was to! Issues a decision to FindLaw & # x27 ; s searchable database of Court of Appeals is more restrictive of. The information provided on this website michigan court of appeals opinions public record, Michigan and federal Law disclosure.