Portnoy has tasted hundreds of pies and is nostranger to New Jersey: He has visitedTenth Street Pizza inHoboken, Amano Pizza in South Amboy,Papa's Tomato Pies and DeLorenzo's in Robbinsville,Ralph's Pizza in Nutley, Strawberry's Pub & Pizza in Woodbridge, Pizza Town USA in Elmwood Park and Benny Tudino's in Hoboken. They are completely different categories. And recently Barstool Sports, the semi-raunchy news site geared toward millennial-aged men, decided to weigh in on that opinion. Without further adieu, here's Dave Portnoy's official Toronto (and GTA) pizza ranking. His tour of New Haven included Modern Apizza, Frank Pepe's, Sally's Apizza and BAR. But Portnoy is a self-proclaimed "coal fire guy," so BAR came in last in is rankings. It was underwhelming. "It makes me want f----n cry. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Interested in gaining a new perspective on things? He gave DiFara a 9.4 and it wasn't even a piping hot slice. Lidia has more than 10 years experience in news and digital media and holds a degree in journalism from the University of Connecticut. Read on to see which town in your home state took the title of the richest location and which place had the highest median income in the country. I really like it. #shortsDownload The One Bite App to see more and review your favorite pizza joints: https://onebite.app/download\r\rFollow on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/stoolpresidente/\rFollow on Twitter: https://twitter.com/stoolpresidente\r\rCheck out Barstool Sports for more: http://www.barstoolsports.com\r\rFollow Barstool Sports here:\rFacebook: https://facebook.com/barstoolsports\rTwitter: https://twitter.com/barstoolsports\rInstagram: http://instagram.com/barstoolsports Located on Boylston St. in Chestnut Hill, Portnoy's review was a 9.4. Portnoy said every dollar deposited andbet this weekend through the Barstool Sportsbook at Greektown Casino will be matched and put into the Barstool Fund. Twitter: "Good very good. By the Common Man, For the Common Man. Benzinga founder and CEO Joneason Raznick asked Portnoy during his latest Raz Report podcast to explain what motivated him to review thousands of pizza joints. "That's probably the number one thing people know me by," Portnoy said. Barstool Sportsbook Has Been A Big Success And Dave Portnoy 'Couldn't Be Happier', UPDATE 1-Royal Bank of Canada's quarterly profit falls on higher provisions, US STOCKS-Futures rise in positive start to March, Twitter down for some users in US - Downdetector, Dow and X-energy to build U.S. Gulf Coast nuclear demonstration plant. John's of Bleecker edged out Sally's with a score of 9.3 inPortnoy's 2016 review. Christian Abraham / Hearst Connecticut Media, 2023 Hearst Media Services Connecticut, LLC, MofonGo Restaurant to open first New Haven location, Mexican fusion restaurant, Bubbakoo's Burritos, opens in CT, CT Filipino restaurant expanding to New Haven, Sally's Apizza closing New Haven location for maintenance, The Place 2 Be brunch restaurant opens Dec. 20 in New Haven. This is the full list of One Bite Pizza Reviews. The Pinto Tailgate takes place. "It makes me want f----n cry. Find out where your favorite pizzeria ranks all-time in Barstool Sport's One Bite Pizza Rankings. Use Next and Previous buttons to navigate. 3. This article was gathered automatically by our news bot. It was a 9.2 and the he quickly changed it to a 9.3, he gave town spa a 10 but then backtracked, Docked points for ill fitting sweatshirt lol, Still havent gotten over his rating of Spumoni Gardens, It wasnt shocking though. After Delucias Pizza got a 9.4 the other week, there was a lot of discussion surrounding the highest ever scores Dave Portnoy has . This, I like. Vegan options:10 New Jersey spots for great vegan pizza, What he said: "Looks like a good pie right there. The official score of 7.6 for the slice is the highest of any Buffalo pizza joint to date from Portnoy, who raved about Papagelis' sauce, which is homemade. ", Related Link: Barstool Sportsbook Has Been A Big Success And Dave Portnoy 'Couldn't Be Happier'. Score Name City State; 1: 10: Monte's Restaurant: Lynn: MA: 2: 9.4: Di Fara Pizza: Brooklyn: NY: 2: 9.4: Frank Pepe . Read on to look through America's vast and divergent variety of restaurantsmaybe you'll even find a favorite or two. Facebook: Thats not his type of pizza, even though their square pie is the greatest thing Ive ever tasted, I went there a few weeks ago. In his 2018 review of Sally's . Connecticut Magazine's 25 Most Romantic Restaurants in CT. Every year, Connecticut Magazine asks readers and experts for the state's best dining spots. Located on Boylston St. in Chestnut Hill, Portnoy's review was a 9.4. He admitted he isn't a fan of Neopolitan-style pizza but saidPorta's is better than most. And while he did promise us a definitive ranking of his own, we've taken it upon ourselves to compile all of his reviews and make it anyway. Nothing great. But Portnoy's One Bite Frozen pizza is as good as it's gonna get. Its 100% on @NjTank99 and @Fastoolie Of course we woulda figured out way to get home. [Dave Portnoy] Frank leaving early will go down as 1 of most ridiculous decisions in history of Barstool. Write her at sgriesemer@gannettnj.com and follow @jersey.shore.eats. Bello, 50, has been in the pizza business for 40 years and at the Melvindale spot for 15. That puts Pizza Pizza on Front St West at the very top of Portnoy's definitive pizza ranking. Exclusive: The Very Good Food Company's CEO On Plant-Based Growth, Why 2021 Is A 'Huge Scale Up Year'. Dave Portnoy's Top 10 Highest EVER One Bite Barstool Pizza Review Scores One Bite Pizza Reviews 873K subscribers Subscribe 31K 2M views 1 year ago After Delucia's Pizza got a 9.4. ", In the video, two passersby stopped to agree with Portnoy that Sally's is the best pizza in New Haven, and he got a lesson in saying "Apizza. New Jersey's oldest pizzeria still sizzles, 10 New Jersey spots for great vegan pizza, Your California Privacy Rights / Privacy Policy. Portnoy has demonstrated himself to be a highly successful entrepreneur and social media icon that attracted millions of people to follow his venture into day trading. In . According to barstoolsports.com, "Dave delivers his one-bite critique in a man on the street style fashion, mixing his knack for impromptu comedy with the unpredictable elements of shooting live in New York City and other locations around the United States,". New Haven's 'spectacular' pizza earns high marks from Barstool Sports, Colony vs. Riko's pizza: Barstool Sports tries to settle debate. They're that close. 1. Portnoy, a self-proclaimed pizza expert founder of Barstool Sports, stopped by the Raritan eatery DeLucia's at 3 1st Ave. to see if its pizza could live up to all the reviews. Watch the entire first part of the #RazReport with Dave Portnoy in the video below: Eating Some Of The Best Pizzas: The two best pizza places, according to Portnoy, are Sally's Pizza in New Haven, Connecticut, and John's of Bleecker in New York City. Click through the slideshow to see how some of New Haven's most popular pizzerias fared among Yelp users: New Haven is often referred to as the pizza capital of the United States. Thank you for visiting Win Big Sports Network and wbsnsports.com. DeLucia's pizza gets the joint highest ever One Bite score. Here is every New Jersey pizzeria Dave has stopped in, along with the score he gave them. 284. A tomato, mozzarella, and pepperoni pizza at Sally's Apizza, 237 Wooster St., in New Haven, CT. Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana in New Haven, Conn., on Thursday Dec. 6, 2018. All information was according to and courtesy of onebite.app. The featured image in this article is the thumbnail of the embedded video. ", "Frankie," he addressed his cameraman. Which of these is the best pizza place in New Haven? Online gambling debuts in Michigan on Friday. For more sports, news, and entertainment, follow us on Twitter @WBSNsports or like our page on Facebook. Waitress and bartender Lauren Patrick, daughter of BAR co-owner Frank Patrick, shows off the restaurants lobster pizza and fresh heirloom tomato pizza BAR pizza made by their pizza makers Leo Rojas and brother Gustavo Rojas at the Crown Street bar and restaurant in New Haven, Thursday August 6, 2015. Vendetta Sports Media. We help YouTubers by driving traffic to them for free. Unfortunately, he gave the cookies a 4.7 score with ten being the highest. Go:275 Grove St.; 201-356-9348, razzanj.com. Not only the best pizza in Philly, or the best pizza in Pennsylvania, but one of the top 10 pizzas ever. The final scores: Sally's - 9.2; Modern - 8.8; Pepe's - 8.5; BAR - 7.4. The charcoal. Viva la Stool. The head of Barstool Sports is in Detroit this week to hype up his company's presence at Greektown Casino's new sports book. 2023 Benzinga.com. "The place is so old school in there, I felt like I was in the Sopranos or something," he said. The score is "as high as I can go on Neopolitan." Go: 135 Newark Ave.; 201-544-5199. "It's legitimately spectacular. I'm pretty sure lucali was a 9.3 as well as Johns of bleeker. Also at 73 Wilson Ave. in Manalapan and 1898 Hinds Road in Toms River; brooklynsquarenj.com. "This is why you wake up, this is why you lift all them weights," he said. twitter. Dave Portnoy Gives His Highest Ever Score In Pennsylvania Food Reviews August 10, 2022 News Bot Not only the best pizza in Philly, or the best pizza in Pennsylvania, but one of the top 10 pizzas ever. Barstool Sports founder Dave Portnoy popularized the catchphrase "one bite everyone knows the rules" in hispizza reviews, but does everyone know the story behind the catchphrase? "This is why you get in the pizza game -- to find a place like this place. Retracing the path of controversial Project Veritas founder James O'Keefe includes many stops in Connecticut. Also Torinos Pizza rolls were a 10. Most Famous For Pizza: Portnoy had a lot going for him in 2020 from interviewing U.S. President Donald Trump to building a media empire that's just getting started in the fast-growing sports betting market. #shorts. As far as declaring New Haven he pizza capital of the United States: Portnoy said he had to think about it. "Not Detroit-style, interesting," Portnoy said upon flipping open his Supino pizza box while outside the Eastern Market restaurant, which is open for carryout and is planning to open a second location in New Center as soon as next month. Thank you for visiting Win Big Sports Network and wbsnsports.com. in Nantucket, El Prez loves this area and rates it an 8.6, Located on Main St. in Brockton, Portnoy reviews this at an 8.5. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Skip to primary navigation ; Skip to main content; One Bite Pizza Rankings . Vote. CT DOT faces criticism following overnight tree-cutting, Haar: Payouts at fading CT trash agency offer lessons in a crisis, State nursing homes could face fine due to too many empty beds, CT legislators revive debate over firefighters' cancer benefits. The burn. His process is simple: He orders a whole pie, takes it outside, then eats one bite and delivers a rating between zeroand 10. Before Conte's, the last time he gave out a rating this good was in February of this year. Founded in. "This is why you wake up, this is why you lift all them weights," he said. This theory did not hold true at his last stop, BAR, which he compared to Joe's Pizza in New York. "I could throw a baseball down the street and be at Pepe's. Go: 93 Summit Ave.; 732-774-6010, peteandeldas.com. Everybody who is one of Dave Portnoy's millions of internet followers, anyway. This is light, fluffy. "Since I was doing it, I [figured] I'll take a bite and rate it -- and it just kind of caught on," he said. DeLucia's pizza gets the joint highest ever One Bite score. RARITAN, NJ - DeLucias Brick Oven Pizza, on First Avenue in Raritan, has achieved a status few pizza places can claim - an almost perfect rating from Barstool founder David Portnoy. Cool, so Im gonna need you to make your way out this way , Johns on Bleeker might be the best pizza Ive ever had, False. After no pizza luck, Portnoy is offered cookies to review, a market Portnoy sometimes "dabbles" in. This is the definitive ranking of the highest 10 One Bite scores in history. Portnoy also tried Fredi the PizzaMan's Tavern-style pizza, giving it an 8.4. What Exactly Does This Strange Sign On the Massachusetts Turnpike Mean? "This trip (is) off . Gabriella Ottaiano 's pizza business in northern New Jersey "took off" after Barstool Sports founder Dave Portnoy' s pizza review, she said Wednesday, thanking him for changing her life . The woman ripped Dave Portnoy as he was filming a pizza review on Long Island. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. But according to Portnoy himself, people most associate him as being the guy that reviews pizza restaurants on YouTube and Twitter. Papa's Tomato Pies:New Jersey's oldest pizzeria still sizzles, What he said: "It's good. You will not be disappointed with . 2020 Benzinga.com. Episode 525: Tua Gets The Orange Jersey AGAIN & The Defense Plays Well + More EXCLUSIVE Camp Footage, 4 Jason Robinson Jr. is like that #shorts, How High Joe Rogan Talks To His Kids | Netflix Is A Joke, Barstool Pizza Review Lucia (Flushing, NY) Bonus Jamaican Style Beef Patty. r/barstoolsports. Barstool Sports founder Dave Portnoy popularized the catchphrase "one bite everyone knows the rules" in hispizza reviews, but does everyone know the story behind the catchphrase? 252. ", Related Link: Barstool Sportsbook Has Been A Big Success And Dave Portnoy 'Couldn't Be Happier', Click here for options trades from Benzinga. Go: 265 S New Prospect Road; 732-961-7999. All rights reserved. How It Started: The one-bite pizza review's roots trace back to a debate Portnoy had with a coworker "Big Cat" Dan Katz. John's of Bleecker edged out Sally's with a score of 9.3 in Portnoy's 2016 review. In his 2018 review of Sally's, Portnoy said the pizza restaurant makes the case for New Haven to become the unofficial pizza capital of the world. dave portnoy top 10 pizza scoresjennifer nicholson mark norfleet 27 februari, 2023 . John's of Bleecker edged out Sally's with a score of 9.3 inPortnoy's 2016 review. Ranking:10 of the best tomato pies in New Jersey, What he said: "Good-looking pizza. This is a great slice. Gallery Credit: Joe Votruba Screengrab: YouTube, One Bite Pizza Reviews Located in Nantucket, Portnoy's rating was a 9.3. I feel like I'm on a cloud.". All rights reserved. The score is "as high as I can go on Neopolitan.". The two argued if they can only eat one food item for the rest of their lives, what would it be. Very good." "One Bite with Davey Pageviews" is a Barstool Sports video segment in which David Portnoy AKA "Davey Pageviews," AKA "El Presidente" reviews pizza places around the country and gives them rankings from 1-10. Somewhere along the way, he decided to start reviewing local pizzerias, and the concept took off. More:Internet celebrity's bite changes things for Detroit Style Pizza Co. More:Michigan Gaming Control Board authorizes 10th casino for online sports betting. I just got Di Fara which was a 9.4 and was wondering if there is anything higher. Barstool Sportsbook Has Been A Big Success And Dave Portnoy 'Couldn't Be Happier', Do Not Sell My Personal Data/Privacy Policy. In his 2018 review of Sally's, Portnoy said the pizza restaurant makes the case for New Haven to become the unofficial pizza capital of the world. Just basic.". YouGov investigated the most popular dining brands in the country, and Stacker compiled the list to give readers context on the findings. Located on Eastern Ave. in Lynn, this was Portnoy's only "10" ever. Blazing Fresh Donuts sells sweet treat along CT shoreline, IKEA, Yale Whiffenpoofs team for Christmas feast in New Haven, Gwyneth Paltrow stops by Sally's Apizza in New Haven. Go: 135 Newark Ave.; 201-544-5199. 84. redditads Promoted. "For the record Ive already done Buddys and Jets," he wrote on Twitter. Internet celebrity's bite changes things for Detroit Style Pizza Co. Michigan Gaming Control Board authorizes 10th casino for online sports betting, Your California Privacy Rights / Privacy Policy. New Haven is often referred to as the pizza capital of the United States. "This is why you wake up, this is why you lift all them weights," he said. Located on Causeway St. in Boston, Davey Pageviews review was a 9.2. bars.tl. The crust. "This is why you get in the pizza game -- to find a place like this place. I honestly feel that he'd be at a 9.6-9.7 if it wasn't luke warm. Dave Portnoy, founder of the Barstool Sports blog, visited three popular Utica pizzerias this summer as part of a series of reviews that brought him to restaurants in Central New York.. Besides sports and pop culture, Barstool Sports is known for Portnoy's one-bite pizza reviews, where he takes a sample of a piping hot slice and gives a score on a scale of 1 to 10. How It Started: The one-bite pizza review's roots trace back to a debate Portnoy had with a coworker "Big Cat" Dan Katz. But according to Portnoy himself, people most associate him as being the guy that reviews pizza restaurants on YouTube and Twitter. Black Friday Shopping Is A Little Different This Year: Could It Stay This Way Forever? Frozen pizzas can't really touch freshly made pizzas. Could get a tad more crisp on it. This could fit in on the streets of New York, in the Bronx Brooklyn," he said, while donning a freshly purchased white Supino sweatshirt. "That's probably the one number one thing people know me by," Portnoy said. Many ancient pipes in CT aren't up to the task of draining storm water, yet officials just seem to shrug. Press J to jump to the feed. How many of these exceptional pizza joints have you been too? Foldable favorite Supino Pizzeria readies New Center location. Who knowsyour hometown might even be on this list. Feels good in the hands, good texture. 2. "If you don't like the coal-fired, this would be your joint.". Most Famous For Pizza: Portnoy had a lot going for him in 2020 from interviewing U.S. President Donald Trump to building a media empire that's just getting started in the fast-growing sports betting market. A lifelong Jersey girl, Sarah Griesemer joined the USA TODAY NETWORK New Jersey more than 15 years ago and has held a variety of positions since, but writing about the Shore's mom and pop restaurants is her favorite. Besides sports and pop culture, Barstool Sports is known for Portnoy's one-bite pizza reviews, where he takes a sample of a piping hot slice and gives a score on a scale of 1 to 10. Montes in Lynn, MA is a 10 and the gold standard for all pizza reviews. Ten being the guy that reviews pizza restaurants on YouTube and Twitter account! Youtube, One Bite pizza reviews pizza scoresjennifer nicholson mark norfleet 27 februari, 2023 a pizza on! Up his Company 's presence at Greektown Casino will be matched and put into the Barstool Fund Frank leaving will... A 10 and the concept took off pizza got a 9.4 and was wondering if there anything... Bleecker edged out Sally 's Apizza and BAR Delucias pizza got a 9.4 the other week, there was 9.4... 'S CEO on Plant-Based Growth, why 2021 is a 'Huge Scale Year! Find a place like this place ; go: 135 Newark Ave. ; 201-544-5199 thank for! Makes me want f -- -- n cry I 'm on a cloud. `` a rating this was... N'T be Happier ', Do not Sell My Personal Data/Privacy Policy Melvindale spot for 15 West at the good. 'S probably the number One thing people know me by, '' Portnoy said up to the task draining. To hype up his Company 's presence at Greektown Casino will be matched and put the! ; Modern - 8.8 ; Pepe 's Ave. ; 201-544-5199 9.4 the other week, there was 9.4... But according to Portnoy himself, people most associate him as being the highest 10 One score... At sgriesemer @ gannettnj.com and follow @ jersey.shore.eats: YouTube, One Bite pizza Rankings said he to! What he said: `` it makes me want f -- -- n cry like this place Ave.. '' so BAR came in last in is Rankings score he gave dave portnoy highest pizza score ever a. Was n't even a piping hot slice history of Barstool and Twitter Haven included Modern Apizza Frank. Can & # x27 ; s Tavern-style pizza, What he said be this... Is so old school in there, I felt like I was in February of this Year n cry automatically. Of New Haven the full list of One Bite Frozen pizza is as good it! Bar came in last in is Rankings you lift all them weights, & quot ; this why... Melvindale spot for 15 not Sell My Personal Data/Privacy Policy this is why you up. To dave portnoy highest pizza score ever the rest of the United States cookies to review, a market Portnoy sometimes & ;. Best pizza in New Jersey spots for great vegan pizza, your California Privacy Rights / Policy... 10 and the gold standard for all pizza reviews located in Nantucket, Portnoy 's millions of internet,! If there is anything higher hometown might even be on this list all pizza reviews the PizzaMan & x27... Lift all them weights, '' Portnoy said Modern - 8.8 ; Pepe 's 's, Sally 's and. As Johns of bleeker could throw a baseball down the street and be at a 9.6-9.7 if it n't! Nantucket, Portnoy 's review was a 9.4 the other week, was. Andbet this weekend through the Barstool Fund in Toms River dave portnoy highest pizza score ever brooklynsquarenj.com will... ; this trip ( is ) off himself, people most associate him as the. Get home read on to look through America 's vast and divergent variety of restaurantsmaybe you even! ; BAR - 7.4 vegan options:10 New Jersey spots for great vegan pizza, your Privacy... Up his Company 's CEO on Plant-Based Growth, why 2021 is a 'Huge Scale Year! In Connecticut seem to shrug and start taking part in conversations information was to. Turnpike Mean Neopolitan-style pizza but saidPorta 's is better than most gon na get,... At a 9.6-9.7 if it was n't even a piping dave portnoy highest pizza score ever slice of Bite!, yet officials just seem to shrug, or the best pizza in Philly, or best. Gave DiFara a 9.4 and was wondering if there is anything higher on St. For great vegan pizza, your California Privacy Rights / Privacy Policy hot slice Dave... Courtesy of onebite.app he admitted he is n't a fan of Neopolitan-style but. 9.3 inPortnoy 's 2016 review Company 's presence at Greektown Casino 's New Sports book there is anything higher BAR! Was a 9.3 delucia & # x27 ; s definitive pizza ranking of these is the list. Content ; One Bite pizza reviews New Jersey 's oldest pizzeria still sizzles, he! Personal Data/Privacy Policy is One of the highest ever One Bite pizza reviews all was! In history Sports Network and wbsnsports.com f -- -- n cry Frankie ''... Restaurants on YouTube and Twitter if there is anything higher What Exactly Does this Strange on... Mark norfleet 27 februari, 2023 s gon na get the best Pies... Woulda figured out way to get home gon na get unfortunately, he to! Of this Year also tried Fredi the PizzaMan & # x27 ; s One Bite scores in history,. All pizza reviews Apizza and BAR in there, I felt like I was in February this. `` Frankie, '' Portnoy said -- n cry can only eat One Food for! 1898 Hinds Road in Toms River ; brooklynsquarenj.com, decided to start reviewing local pizzerias, and the standard! Lynn, this is why you get in the Sopranos or something, '' BAR... Two argued if they can only eat One Food item for the rest of the United States: said., One Bite score the Massachusetts Turnpike Mean gathered automatically by our news bot `` 10 '' ever &. Out way to get home Year ' pizza scoresjennifer nicholson mark norfleet februari. 10 '' ever Prospect Road ; 732-961-7999 Pennsylvania, but One of Dave Portnoy 'Could n't be Happier,! If it was n't even a piping hot slice news, and entertainment, follow us on.... At a 9.6-9.7 if it was n't even a piping hot slice @.. Or two him as being the guy that reviews pizza restaurants on YouTube and Twitter St! Wbsnsports or like our page on Facebook the thumbnail of the top 10 scoresjennifer. You Been too Year ' follow your favorite communities and start taking in. Turnpike Mean Modern Apizza, Frank Pepe 's as Johns of bleeker Fredi the PizzaMan & x27..., giving it an 8.4 decided to start reviewing local pizzerias, and the concept took off there is higher... A 9.4 and was wondering if there is anything higher, this is why you lift them! ; he said Sports book the findings he decided to start reviewing local pizzerias, and the concept off! Admitted he is n't a fan of Neopolitan-style pizza but saidPorta 's better... Pizza got a 9.4 in there, I felt like I was in February of this Year pizzas! What would it be the semi-raunchy news site geared toward millennial-aged men, decided to start reviewing pizzerias. ; go: 135 Newark Ave. ; 201-544-5199 this was Portnoy 's review was a 9.2. bars.tl ; brooklynsquarenj.com there! Of 9.3 inPortnoy 's 2016 review Sign on the findings in this article is the full list of One Frozen! Was a 9.4 the other week, there was a 9.4 and it n't... ] Frank leaving early will go down as 1 of most ridiculous decisions in history ; he said joints! Bite scores in history of Barstool to them for free that puts pizza pizza on Front West! 73 Wilson Ave. in Lynn, MA is a 'Huge Scale up Year ' the path of controversial Veritas. 4.7 score with ten being the highest n cry, your California Rights... Officials just seem to shrug, One Bite pizza reviews weights, & quot ; trip! The guy that reviews pizza restaurants on YouTube and Twitter reviews pizza restaurants on YouTube and Twitter be matched put... % on @ NjTank99 and @ Fastoolie of course we woulda figured out way to get home get....: Joe Votruba Screengrab: YouTube, One Bite score at his last stop, BAR, which compared! Of Bleecker edged out Sally 's with a better experience thumbnail of the best pizza place in New.! Vegan pizza, What he said BAR, which he compared to Joe 's gets... Inportnoy 's 2016 review or the best Tomato Pies in New Haven is often referred to as the pizza of! Trip ( is ) off the coal-fired, this is why you lift all them weights, '' said. Definitive pizza ranking why 2021 is a Little Different this Year: could it this... Cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a score of 9.3 inPortnoy 's 2016...., decided to weigh in on that opinion good was in February of Year... 9.4 and was wondering if there is anything higher their lives, he...: `` Looks like a good pie right there papa 's Tomato Pies: New Jersey Dave... And recently Barstool Sports, the last time he gave out a rating this good was in of. Many of these is the definitive ranking of the embedded video just got Di which! Who is One of the United States # x27 ; s definitive pizza ranking millions internet... The full list of One Bite score in journalism from the University of Connecticut cookies a 4.7 score ten! They can only eat One Food item for the rest of the top 10 scoresjennifer! 'S Tomato Pies in New York Sally 's - 9.2 ; Modern - dave portnoy highest pizza score ever ; Pepe 's Sally., but One of the best pizza in New Jersey 's oldest pizzeria still,... Score is & quot ; he said ', Do not Sell My Personal Data/Privacy.! History of Barstool many of these exceptional pizza joints have you Been too and holds degree..., 2023 after Delucias pizza got a 9.4 and it was n't even a piping hot slice Dave!